Album Review by: Cheryl Harvey Hill
I just finished listening to Remembering Patsy Cline and I'm in
shock. I didn't think it was possible to ruin the outstanding songs that
Cline recorded. I was wrong. Very, very wrong. The artists on this album
should issue a public apology to Willie Nelson, Harlan Howard, Hank
Cochran, Mel Tillis and all of the other great songwriters who wrote
these tunes. I understand that the artists were not trying
to sound like the great Ms. Cline but good grief ... they are singing
some of the finest songs ever written ... you would think that they
could muster up some of her passion for the music. The only person who
even came close was Jessi Alexander with her version of "So
Wrong." After hearing the other artists renditions I found it
difficult to believe they ever even heard Cline sing and it appears that
they all struggled while "remembering."
The first song on the album is the classic, "I Fall To Pieces"
sung by Natalie Cole. It was so bad that I suffered through only the
first chorus before I had to fast forward to the next song which was
Norah Jones rendition of "Why Can't He Be You." It was
dreadful. Jones successfully managed to totally ruin one of my all time
favorite songs so I quickly fast forwarded to the next song; "Back
In Baby's Arms" by Amy Grant. I give Grant some credit because at
least the song was somewhat recognizable but the album went rapidly
downhill after that. When I got to "Strange" by Michelle
Branch it was so bad that I had to stop listening for a while.
The other singers; Terri Clark, Lee Ann Womack, Martina McBride, kd lang;
all distinguished artists that I've come to expect great music from.
"She's Got You," "Leavin' On Your Mind," "Walkin'
After Midnight, and "Sweet Dreams" are among the most splendid
songs ever written. I was ready to love this album. I was sure I was
going to hear some remarkable renditions of true country classics. I
didn't. The album was a major disappointment.
On a scale of one to ten this one isn't even a blip on the radar! What
were they thinking?!?!?!?! At least they had the good sense not
to call it a tribute to Pasty -- because is ISN'T. Save